Fake stories in the Non-Fiction section?

[Qazwox27]

What is this site's general attitude towards these stories? Some of the stories in that section are obviously fake, but a lot of those are even still well-received by the audience. Do we have a "live and let live" outlook on these? Personally, I find that they are watering down that section and I'd prefer they weren't there.

[Fango]

How can you tell they are "obviously fake"? Just because a story is written in a "fictional" writing style doesn't make it fake. Unless there are clear fantasy/sci-fi elements in a story, how can you truly judge something as fiction?

Fango

[Qazwox27]

For example:
https://forum.oneclickchicks.com/showthread.php?t=166349

There are photos in that thread that are allegedly of the poster, but those photos belong to a different Reddit user that has gone by several usernames. Currently, that user posts as /u/awhha (she posted as /u/6mmshhh9 before and had other names before that). awhha deleted those pictures years ago, presumably because they showed her face. awhha is not the same person as aryaisthebest, their writing styles and life stories don't match up. awhha is currently in college, but aryaisthebest claims to have left college years ago.

Plus, going through aryaisthebest's post history on reddit, a lot of them just aren't plausible. One of them involves a masseur giving her an unsolicited "happy ending."

Another thread:
https://forum.oneclickchicks.com/showthread.php?t=166281

Some user already called this one out, but the thread was never moved or moderated in any way.

Generally, I'm skeptical of most threads posted from a female perspective and catering only to male fantasy, but you're right, I couldn't prove all of them fake. I'm not sure if these threads give off the wrong vibe to anyone else. Maybe other people don't care or would rather not know. I made this post out of curiosity as to what others think.

[Fango]

Originally Posted by Qazwox27

For example:
https://forum.oneclickchicks.com/showthread.php?t=166349

There are photos in that thread that are allegedly of the poster, but those photos belong to a different Reddit user that has gone by several usernames. Currently, that user posts as /u/awhha (she posted as /u/6mmshhh9 before and had other names before that). awhha deleted those pictures years ago, presumably because they showed her face. awhha is not the same person as aryaisthebest, their writing styles and life stories don't match up. awhha is currently in college, but aryaisthebest claims to have left college years ago.

Plus, going through aryaisthebest's post history on reddit, a lot of them just aren't plausible. One of them involves a masseur giving her an unsolicited "happy ending."

You should post this information in that thread. At least give aryaisthebest a chance to defend themselves (or scurry away with their tail between their legs).

Originally Posted by Qazwox27

Another thread:
https://forum.oneclickchicks.com/showthread.php?t=166281

Some user already called this one out, but the thread was never moved or moderated in any way.

I'm not sure if these threads give off the wrong vibe to anyone else. Maybe other people don't care or would rather not know. I made this post out of curiosity as to what others think.

This post has also been reported twice as being fiction, and is actually the post I made a thinly veiled reference to in my last post as having a "'fictional' writing style". I'll be honest: I have not had a chance to read it. But just from skimming it, I can't tell what about it causes people to think that it absolutely has to be fiction. Again, if there aren't fantasy or sci-fi elements in the story, how can you tell? Just because it's written like a short story doesn't necessarily make it fiction by default. If there are key passages that you think tag this story as fiction, please quote them so I can make a more informed decision.

Fango