This post is about the punishment/payback L and S received back in August (post #88). The backstory is that L was at school, and we were doing a late-night sexting/facetime where she was under the covers and led me to believe that she had her Lush in and was enjoying herself while I controlled it. I thought it was unusual that she was under the covers, but not enough to question her about it. We played back and forth for a bit until her phone wobbled around, and then S appeared next to her with the sheets pulled up to her neck, too.
Both of them reacted every time I turned the Lush up and down, which turned out to be totally acting! They yanked the covers down and were fully dressed with the Lush sandwiched between them so that they both could feel it vibrate. They were quite proud of fooling me, and I have to give them credit… I was completely worked up even though I never saw anything below their necks.
When we hung up for the night, I tried putting on my best poker face, telling them how disappointed I was in the two of them and how I needed to think about their punishment. The more they reacted to that, the more I poured it on, too. L started txting me as soon as we hung up, asking if I was really mad and what I was going to do. I have no doubt that S was looking right over her shoulder as she txted me, too.
Over the rest of the week, I built up the talk about their "punishment" for what they did to me. It took on a life of its own for a few days, where every call or txt turned to them being sorry and trying to get details about what I had planned… which at that point I had no idea what I would try to get them to do.
One of my friends on here has heard more about this, but I’m really torn at times about pushing the whole S situation. Being naked around S isn’t new, but I still have a fear that things will go bad and L will get mad, or what was mutual at the time will morph into something different (i.e., me making her uncomfortable or a completely different memory of how things went, later on). I don’t want to be posting in the missed opportunities thread later, but I don’t want to mess anything up with L, or S for that matter. Quite a mind-fuck, to be honest… it is like everyone is waiting for one of the others to take charge.
Back to the punishment… I knew S was getting a readout on what I was txting and telling L, so was playing it up quite a bit. I told L how badly I had blue balls after that and how awful it was being home alone without her to help me. It was all silly, but we went back and forth all week about how she would make it up to me and make me feel better. I played up how much I looked forward to that, but I didn’t know how S would make it up to me since she was equally part of the cause. When I txted that, it probably took 5 minutes to get a response back from L, and I honestly thought that I had just screwed up! The wait seemed like hours, and I hoped the response would be “keep dreaming” or something like that, instead of scorched earth! When I finally got an answer, it was “she promises to make it up to you, too,” with a little smiley face blowing a kiss. Being a guy, I went from feeling like I was going to die to cloud nine instantly. So much for learning a lesson, haha.
I kept the teasing up and txted that I didn’t think S could take the same punishment as she could and that I thought she would chicken out. I didn’t have to wait 5 minutes this time. Probably 30 seconds after sending my txt, my screen lit up with an incoming facetime call from L. A complete emotional roller coaster ride… I thought I had fucked up originally, I thought I hit the lottery, and then back to feeling like I fucked up! I don’t remember how many times I let it ring, but it was probably a handful of times before I hit accept. Before I could even say anything, L was talking, and talking trash, about their punishment. I don’t remember the exact exchange word for word, but she would make a comment and then turn her phone to S.
I had probably thought about this at some level, but it just came out while L was pushing me on their punishment. I told them that they cheated me out of 3 orgasms, which got an immediate “3?” reaction until I reminded them that they each faked one, and of course mine. L gave me that squinty-eyed smirk, and S just sort of grinned. I needed to go and left them with this… if they had robbed a bank, they would have to pay back the money, and there would be other penalties included, and I was still thinking about the rest. I really did have to jump on a work call, so my abrupt “got to go” while they were both chattering at me wasn’t a complete lie, but it was a little evil. I think I had 15 missed txt messages from her while I was on my call.
Friday evening seemed to take forever to get here, and the plan was for S to come home with L. Usually, L isn’t home until five or sixish, but they made it there around 4. When I got the txt that they were on their way and early, I was a little torn up over what to do. Act like normal and see how the night/weekend went or go straight to it. When L pulled in the garage, I helped them bring their bags and dirty clothes in, and I decided to just go for it. I’d either get laughed off, or not
. I looked at L and asked her why she still had her clothes on and got a look from her that was almost a are you daring me expression. L liked to tease me walking around naked, so it wasn’t all that unusual. I love stripping her and pulling her shirt up and over her head… of course that didn’t go exactly as planned, and once I got the shirt unstuck from her head and her standing there in her bra and jeans, I unclasped her bra and tossed it to the floor. I unbuckled her jeans and plopped her on the couch so I could tug them off by the legs. With her legs in the air, I pulled her panties up and off, tossing them with the rest of her clothes.
S was just a spectator at this point and still standing there until L started to undress her on her own. I did feel a little affirmed that as sexy as I try to strip L, I never quite pull it off in a sexy way… tight jeans always get stuck, panties pull half-off, and a head or arm gets stuck. L undressing S wasn’t any better
. L started trying to undress me, and because I’m a lot taller than her, she always takes my shorts and underwear off first… so a super sexy look standing there bottomless with a shirt on
.
I didn’t have anything after this planned out and just winged it. I asked L if she had brought her Lush home, and she had. Since they teased me with the Lush, I told her that one of their orgasms needed to be with the Lush. We moved back to our bedroom, and I thought I might need to get some lube, but L was soaking wet. S was just sort of standing there, and I told her to lay on the bed by L, which she sort of awkwardly did. I had L lick her Lush, and then I ran it up and down her slit a few times and inserted it inside her. I took L’s phone, started the Lovense app, and played with the control. I eventually handed it over to S while I slowly tugged it in and out of L’s pussy, until she came, which was pretty fast. L was so creamy and absolutely coated the Lush, too. L was almost shaking when I held the Lush and told her to lick it. Not nervous, like she didn't want to, but it looked her heart was about to explode from her chest she was so worked up.
There was a slightly awkward pause about what would happen next, but L took over She pushed S back on the bed and was in charge, taking the Lush and rubbing it on her slit before slowly feeding it until S’s pussy almost sucked it inside. I used the app, and L tugged/pushed it in and out of S. S must have lasted just a minute or two, from start to finish, before she tightened up and came. I won’t lie… I was a little bummed that they both came so fast and literally thought that we would be done within 20 minutes of them coming home.
I don’t know if any of you can visualize this, but L was up on her knees holding the Lush by the tail like she caught it, with S still on her back recovering. It just sort of came out because of habit, but I asked L if she was going to clean it up… and she popped S’s creamy Lush right into her mouth. That might not seem all that hot to any of you, but I thought my heart was going to pound out of my chest watching L clean up S’s grool. I put the Lush back in L and cranked it to high for about 30 seconds before pulling it out. In hindsight, it seems funny now, but I almost shoved it in S’s face, and she licked it clean.
I was so focused on the two of them, and then I instantly became aware of how hard and excited I was. I got L on her knees and slid into her… and I was over the top sensitive… I was afraid I’d cum too fast, and things would be over. We flipped around, and I honestly lost track of S and what she was doing, other than knowing she was on the bed with us. L rode me for a little bit, and I repeatedly had to have her slow down and completely stop a few times. When she climbed off of me, I could see that she how much she coated me, too. I said something like, "now I need a clean up," and I thought L would go down on me and maybe put on a bit of show for S. Instead, L practically dragged S over and shoved her mouth down onto me. Shove might be too strong, but you get the idea, and S didn't fight it. I leaned back on the bed on my elbows, trying to watch, but there was so much fucking long hair everywhere I couldn’t see anything!!! I could feel licking along my shaft and then a mouth around the head. It was an unbelievable feeling. I had to make them slow down, and then they just completely stopped.
They got off of the bed, and I scooted down to the end, but still sitting on the bed. We both like it when L backs into me (reverse cowgirl) while I’m sitting on the edge of the bed. L started doing that and probably slid up and down my cock ten times or so before she stopped and dismounted. I kind of hoped that they would be back to cleaning my dick up together… instead, L woman handled S to the same position she had been in. Not a fight from S, but she almost acted like she didn’t understand what was happening. I admit I wasn't sure either. I couldn’t really see anything other than the back of S as she very slowly lowered herself down on me while a hand guided me in. S’s legs were shaking so much she could hardly stand as she sunk down on me. No sliding up and down… she just slowly worked her way all the way down my dick, and then I could feel her pulsing and clamp down. It took me a second to realize what had happened. I would have loved to let her sit there for a little while, but as soon as it registered, I felt like I was going to cum at any second. I barely got out of her before I started spraying cum all over the place! Real life… is it a good or a bad thing when you need to run the carpet cleaner after sex?
I’d like to tell you that the three of us play all the time together, but nothing like that has happened since. With a bit of encouragement from a friend on here (you know who you are), I’m going to try and turn things up a little. Things have not been weird for the three of us, but I think they have been waiting on me to make the next move. L and like to talk dirty during sex, and I talk about S cleaning up her creampie, which L REALLY likes. I know I’m being too paranoid, but I’m trying to set up some more fun without ruining things. For Christmas, I bought L some naughty presents, which included two jeweled butt plugs. I got two because I thought she would like the colors, lol, but when I gave them to L, she asked me who the second one was for… and I jokingly told her S. I followed up with that I thought S might be too afraid to use it and laughed. L told me I should ask her
. On a side note, L wore her new butt plug to Christmas dinner and drove me crazy by looking at me and wiggling around in her chair!
One of the other fun things I got us is a sex swing. I bought a stand because my ceiling is really high, and I didn’t want to screw an eye bolt into it. Of course, the stand was delayed, but it got here on Tuesday. Nothing like testing out the sex swing in the middle of the family room
. We had never used one before but got the hang of it really fast! So far, we both really like it when I just barely enter her and swing her back and forth ever so slightly, teasing her pussy with just the first inch or so of my cock. Of course, we got busted today when her mom popped over, and the swing was still set up in the family room. A hundred questions about is that what I think it is, how you get in it…. The questioning eventually got a loud “MOoooommmmm” from L. I joked with her later and asked if she was going to let her mom and dad borrow her swing, haha. You can imagine the reaction I got