I find make up of any kind except eyeliner to be a light turnoff. Not a dealbreaker or cockblocker kinda thing but I prefer women with a natural look. Bold finger or toe nail polish as well, I just prefer not to see it.
I like women's feet but for some reason only from behind or underneath. In porn I like it when you see the soles of a woman's bare feet when she is on all fours or on her stomach or giving head, but I don't really like any other attention to her toenails or foot worship, etc. Got no idea why, but whatever