Would You Rather - The Return
 

Forgive me for starting another thread like this. The old one got kinda sloppy in my opinion and I don’t want to take it over so figured I’d start fresh. If there’s any issue with that feel free to delete, mods. I’ll try to pose a question every week or so. Some may be similar in nature to the ones in the old thread but many are worth revisiting anyway.

QUESTION #1
Your wife agrees to be shared in a threesome with you and another guy. Would you rather it be someone you know or a total stranger?

For me it’s a turn on either way but I definitely fantasize more about this with specific friends of mine. In particular my best friend who she has admitted to finding attractive. Even going as far to say she would choose him specifically for a three way. We’d never act on this but I often find myself fantasizing about her blowing us both and taking turns with her and making her have the night of her life. If we were to ever go down this path we’d probably try to find someone online so we wouldn’t have the awkwardness afterwards of it being a friend. But I think that’s what makes it all the more arousing as a fantasy.

For me we’ve done both-

For a random threesome definitely on of my or our friends! Especially one that is around for a lot of parties and holidays.

For something ongoing (like a consistent bull or boyfriend) a stranger. Very hot having consistent mystery from the people around us.

Both
 

One night my wife was pretty drunk and I had been fantasizing about a threesome, we were drinking on the deck and she goes to bed. I so desperately wanted to ask my buddy but was afraid of being turned down or being jealous. So I didn’t ask, but I was close.
Another time my wife and I were in Mexico vacationing when we started drinking 2fers, there was a young college aged guy there with his sister. I think she was gay and was saying sexually charged comments to my wife. We had gotten pretty horny and was getting ready to leave, I had been playing with her pussy in the pool and she had part of her pussy exposed to this kid and didn’t even know it. I’m sure I could have gotten him to come to the room but was to scared to pull the trigger.

"If" being the objective word...if that was to ever happen I'd prefer a complete stranger.

My reasoning is simple. If the other guy was to make her cum/squirt hard, she might get "hooked" on that cock if it belonged to someone close. Then I might have to deal with the aftermath of my wife longing for more of it. If it's someone she has zero chances of staying in contact with, then it's just a nice memory.
I'm pragmatic about these things lol!:rolleyes:

I would rather the other person be someone I know. At least someone I have spoken with at times and have got to know well enough to have a positive opinion of. My wife wouldn't have gone along with the whole thing if she wasn't confident I was alright with the fellow.

Wife and I both have this fantasy she would be blindfolded while fucking and sucking another guy.
Then afterwards, I would hand her a note with 5 names of people she knows ... 1 of them just fucked her.

Other than that, I think it wouldn't matter if it was a stranger or someone we know.
As long as there is a click and the other person would be able to keep his mouth shut afterwards.
But till that day comes, we'll have to manage by the fantasy :)

I am the same as OP. I have arranged instances for my wife to be nude in front of both strangers and friends of mine but it’s somehow WAY hotter when it’s the guys I know. Partly because I know it’s hotter for her. I think it’s the same as say, would you rather see naked photos of a stranger or a gal you work with or your wife’s friends? It’s definitely sexier when you know them. So knowing my wife has fantasized about a specific guy then fucked him is sexier than hooking up with a stranger. But we’d never actually do that as it could ruin the friendship. So we’d probably take the route of arranging a threesome with a stranger. To be honest I’d be open to both and hope someday it works out

happy this thread is back
 

QUESTION #1
Your wife agrees to be shared in a threesome with you and another guy. Would you rather it be someone you know or a total stranger?

This is an easy one for us. We talk a lot about thruways. She loves the idea of being fucked by another man with me there. We've been close a few times. Without a doubt it would be someone we know. One of my friends has nude pictures of her (I've posted about it on other threads). She and I have "used" him in fantasy role-play threesomes.

She's been flirty with him at different times with some alcohol flowing. At this point, it's getting over that hurdle. From talking and wanting, to actually doing it.

For me(husband)/us would prefer it to be a stranger, perhaps on holiday?

Thanks for bringing this back. I had basically run out of ideas for questions.

Question 1. I don’t see either happening in real life, but if it did happen I know my wife and I would prefer a friend. I have a particular friend in mind because he would be discrete and my wife really likes him.